Infra pubic or infra scrotal?

[BillinAL]

I think it has a lot to do with the surgeon and there has got to be some luck involved. My first implant in 2014 was done infra-pubic. I lost no feeling - I had no issues with the recovery. All went very smooth, but the implant failed at almost exactly three years. Both tubes broke close to the cylinders.
I decided to have the revision done scrotally because I was hoping that only the pump would have to be replaced and the scrotal approach seem to make more sense. I selected a high volume doctor - Dr Kramer and had it done in July 2017 - about 7 months ago. I had a severe reaction to the anaesthesia which caused me extreme nausea every two hours for about two weeks - night and day. As soon as I had much feeling come back at about 3 weeks, I immediately recognized that the pump was way too high (on my first implant the pump was perfectly positioned). It has remained too high and is difficult to pump unless I get in the tub. Because of the high pump, the release on the other end of the pump is all the way to the very top of my scrotum and extremely difficult to get to to operate. Since the pump is not low in the scrotum, all the extra tubing is bunched up on the side of my scrotum. In addition, the bottom side of my penis is numb. I think this is because I had a nerve in my scrotum cut, and it was sewn up into the scar where the incision was made. It was very painful to even touch for 6 months but the nerve is slowly dying, I guess, because the pain is starting to go away, but the numbness in my penis remains. Overall, this implant is usable but just barely. My first reaction after about 2 months is that I would have a revision, but I have had so many problems with this surgery/recovery that I simply am not up for another one. The first implant spoiled me re: ease of position and operation of pump and release, easy recovery, and no loss of sensitivity.
So to the question - scrotal vs infra-pubic - there are no guarantees.

[ocitgo]

I find the high volume doctors can make more mistakes. They can goes far faster Infra pubic but mistakes are more problematic. It is like brain surgery. I watched the mentioned discussion just last night.

[Donnie1954]

I had infra pubic. Back in action in 28 days. Absolutely no regrets. No complications. Thank God.
Donnie