ksndvt wrote:M 25 trouble maintaining erections.
Now, non malleable implants have chances of mechanical failure compare to malleable ones.
Did people with malleable implants had other drawbacks ( except its always erect, its. a blessing when young)
You will get answers to your questions from current members and they will trickle in over the next couple of weeks.
If you want to get answers much quicker and some answers that you may never get (because some members are no longer active) I recommend what I did when I first joined FrankTalk. I took a couple weekends to read through a few years of posts/threads with titles that interested me and appeared informative. It will give you a better basis for forming questions and understanding the answers.
Here is one thread from autumn 2019. There are many others from earlier. Search function is your friend. Look for "malleable" and "remi-rigid"
viewtopic.php?f=21&p=135859#p135859This knowledge will also help get your medical team to accept you as a contributing partner in the decision-making.
I also recommend doing extensive research on your chosen urologist/sexual health physician and interview him (or her) pointedly and make yourself an integral part of the medical team. (Of course, many men choose not to do that and I cannot fault them - just do what is comfortable for your personality and approach to your medical care.)
I recommend documenting your size (length and girth) by careful measurement and photographs. Make sure your measurement protocol is repeatable (you will want to measure after surgery also). The most widely used measurement is to press a measuring tool against your pubic bone just above your penis, compressing the pubic fat pad as much as possible and measuring (straight) to the tip of your penis (not following the curve around to the tip, but just straight out like a shoe store measures your foot to the tip of your toe - but you can follow the curve of your penis' shaft.) Girth is measurement of circumference at the midpoint of your penis. Some choose to find the girthiest part, instead. Usually the two points are the same or very close.
Much discussion has been had about the relative merits of malleable vs inflatable implants. The quality of life (both when inflated for sexual activities and uninflated for the rest of your day) is MUCH better with the inflatables. Inflatables do fail after a time. They are more complex and mechanical failures do affect the service life. The surgery is more complex, increasing the risk of complications (like infection) and the cost. Malleables hardly ever fail mechanically but as has been pointed out, being full-size and stiff all day every day has drawbacks both to your penis tissue health and day to day activities. For example, tight-fitting bathing suits or pants, deploying for urination and stowing away afterwards are just two of the problems that one must deal with.
"always erect, its. a blessing when young" is illusory. When young, you can wear clothes that you may find embarrassing at poolside, certain social events (family gatherings, church, etc).
I encourage you to read past posts. They are full of answers to your questions.
Also, do not jump to an implant right away. There are less invasive, risky and expensive treatments that could provide relief to you for years. Those years might even produce a true cure for you. It is important to note that an implant does not cure E.D. It makes it worse, in fact. If guarantees 100% impotence until you inflate. If you had a hand that did not grip well, would you cut it off for replacement with a prosthetic hand? Keep in mind that the prosthetic may fail and leave you worse off than your natural hand was until you undergo another surgery. Or if you could struggle through a 9 minute mile on your own feet, would you opt for prosthetic feet that enabled a 4 minute mile, but if (when) they failed, would leave you in a wheelchair until undergoing another surgery?
Welcome to the forum, ksndvt