Page 1 of 4
I can't understand why every surgeon doesn't copy Dr Eid's protocol
Posted: Sun Jan 15, 2023 6:24 am
by Bwtbbb
Dr. Eid has the lowest infection rate and gets seemingly the best results. He has done the most implants and has the most experience.
I can't understand why other surgeons don't copy his approach to anaesthesia, surgery, stitching, recovery, bathing, cycling and more.
Re: I can't understand why every surgeon doesn't copy Dr Eid's protocol
Posted: Sun Jan 15, 2023 8:05 am
by crazyjoe
It’s a good question. I believe he credits his “no touch’ method to his nearly zero infection rate. I’m not medical but sounds like his hands are not in direct contact, only his instruments.
Re: I can't understand why every surgeon doesn't copy Dr Eid's protocol
Posted: Sun Jan 15, 2023 8:48 am
by Bwtbbb
crazyjoe wrote:It’s a good question. I believe he credits his “no touch’ method to his nearly zero infection rate. I’m not medical but sounds like his hands are not in direct contact, only his instruments.
That seems to be the one thing the other surgeons actually did copy.
Re: I can't understand why every surgeon doesn't copy Dr Eid's protocol
Posted: Sun Jan 15, 2023 10:09 am
by Txagq8
Bwtbbb:
This is a question.
Where are you seeing actual published statistics which show his and other surgeons’ actual infection rates?
I’m not being a prick. I’m just a stickler for truth, facts, and being able to support a statement. There’s a lot of subjectivity in implant land. But infection rate isn’t one of them. Where are you seeing various doctors’ numbers compared?
Re: I can't understand why every surgeon doesn't copy Dr Eid's protocol
Posted: Sun Jan 15, 2023 10:20 am
by KeithC
Not everyone has even heard of Dr Eid. Including me.
Re: I can't understand why every surgeon doesn't copy Dr Eid's protocol
Posted: Sun Jan 15, 2023 10:25 am
by Bwtbbb
Txagq8 wrote:Bwtbbb:
This is a question.
Where are you seeing actual published statistics which show his and other surgeons’ actual infection rates?
I’m not being a prick. I’m just a stickler for truth, facts, and being able to support a statement. There’s a lot of subjectivity in implant land. But infection rate isn’t one of them. Where are you seeing various doctors’ numbers compared?
He told me that his infection rate is the lowest.
I don't know other surgeons' rates but if you ask your surgeon they should be able to tell you their infection rate.
I thought it was common knowledge that his 0.6% infection rate was the lowest. It is on the Peyronie's forum at least.
Re: I can't understand why every surgeon doesn't copy Dr Eid's protocol
Posted: Sun Jan 15, 2023 10:38 am
by newbie443
Txagq8 wrote:Bwtbbb:
This is a question.
Where are you seeing actual published statistics which show his and other surgeons’ actual infection rates?
I’m not being a prick. I’m just a stickler for truth, facts, and being able to support a statement. There’s a lot of subjectivity in implant land. But infection rate isn’t one of them. Where are you seeing various doctors’ numbers compared?
https://www.garber-online.com/pdf/Highe ... ctions.pdf
Re: I can't understand why every surgeon doesn't copy Dr Eid's protocol
Posted: Sun Jan 15, 2023 11:20 am
by crazyjoe
His claimed infection rate is 0.4% -- so would be 4 out of 1,000.
Re: I can't understand why every surgeon doesn't copy Dr Eid's protocol
Posted: Sun Jan 15, 2023 4:42 pm
by JetsFan1594
KeithC wrote:Not everyone has even heard of Dr Eid. Including me.
How much time have you spent on this forum? He’s certainly the most used + discussed surgeon on here, and arguably on Earth.
There are other great surgeons though of course- Perito, Clavell, Hakky, Karpman etc etc
Re: I can't understand why every surgeon doesn't copy Dr Eid's protocol
Posted: Sun Jan 15, 2023 4:47 pm
by KeithC
JetsFan1594 wrote:KeithC wrote:Not everyone has even heard of Dr Eid. Including me.
How much time have you spent on this forum? He’s certainly the most used + discussed surgeon on here, and arguably on Earth.
There are other great surgeons though of course- Perito, Clavell, Hakky, Karpman etc etc
I had an implant 12 weeks ago. I have no reason to research other implant doctors 1,500 miles away.
So what percentage of users here have traveled to NYC and been implanted by Dr. Eid? Just curious.