FrankTalk.org

With the increase in IPP 3 piece failure- I believe people need to know their options when considering an implant.

I been on this forum for over 2 years now and I’ve seen little to no feedback/pictures on malleable.

For some of us young guys the smartest decision we can make is choosing an implant if we’ve exhausted ever other options in the market for ED, BUT as a young person it’s also difficult to imagine 3-4 revisions down the road when choosing to get implanted


Just some food for thought. Good day!

The problem with malleables for a long period is they can cause erosion and glans atrophy. I have heard this from both Dr. Perito and Dr Eid on Youtube although I don't have the sources at my fingertips.

That said I think about malleables also. I'm hoping to get implanted this year with an AMS CX, but if I have several quick failures or an infection I think about the Tactra. I do worry about tissue atrophy with malleables

Pamen116 wrote:With the increase in IPP 3 piece failure- I believe people need to know their options when considering an implant.
(edited for focus)

Yes, people do need to know their options and there is VERY little discussion about malleables. I also must point out that the "increase in IPP 3 piece failure' is illusory. The rate of failures is unlikely to be higher than in previous years. More likely a result of more reporting.

On FrankTalk, there is next to nothing on malleable prostheses....and frankly it is very discouraging for those considering one. Besides the lack of information, there is considerable bias against malleable implants on this platform, with people who have never had them claiming with authority that a malleable will never be truly comfortable or that the risk of constant pain and erosion with a semi-rigid devices are greater than with IPPs.

The rate of failure of IPPs is very real -there are multiple possible failure points- and with each successive surgery, the prospects of infection, scarring and reduced size all are worth considering when deciding which route to take.

On the other hand, if implanted correctly, a malleable implant may last for years -perhaps much longer than an IPP- and many men who have malleables claim that once they get used to their prosthesis, they stop becoming aware that they have one.

The rhetoric against malleable implants can at least partially be traced to the manufacturing companies pushing the more expensive devices and doctors doing the same (higher surgical fees), knowing that multiple surgeries potentially lie ahead.

At any rate, for those interested in malleable implants (or for those who have already been implanted with one), there is a whatapp group that one may join:

https://chat.whatsapp.com/FJYnpIGClI98xPWHAYxk3H

Dapkin wrote:On FrankTalk, there is next to nothing on malleable prostheses....and frankly it is very discouraging for those considering one. Besides the lack of information, there is considerable bias against malleable implants on this platform, with people who have never had them claiming with authority that a malleable will never be truly comfortable or that the risk of constant pain and erosion with a semi-rigid devices are greater than with IPPs.

The rate of failure of IPPs is very real -there are multiple possible failure points- and with each successive surgery, the prospects of infection, scarring and reduced size all are worth considering when deciding which route to take.

On the other hand, if implanted correctly, a malleable implant may last for years -perhaps much longer than an IPP- and many men who have malleables claim that once they get used to their prosthesis, they stop becoming aware that they have one.

The rhetoric against malleable implants can at least partially be traced to the manufacturing companies pushing the more expensive devices and doctors doing the same (higher surgical fees), knowing that multiple surgeries potentially lie ahead.

At any rate, for those interested in malleable implants (or for those who have already been implanted with one), there is a whatapp group that one may join:

https://chat.whatsapp.com/FJYnpIGClI98xPWHAYxk3H

I won't argue with you. Perhaps its a culture difference. Malleables just are not seen as replicating a natural penis very well. That is the feature that most westerners seem to want. What is seen by many cultures as big down sides. Like costs & revisions have relatively easy solutions here in many cases.

In countries where insurance isn't common. These down sides are a bigger issue. Just not a huge concern here. I'm sure that you've seen that many Americans are willing to get revisions. While they don't like them, they are generally covered by insurance.

I think the best answer is that someone needs to start a forum like FT but centered around the societies of the eastern world.

Dapkin wrote:On FrankTalk, there is next to nothing on malleable prostheses....and frankly it is very discouraging for those considering one. Besides the lack of information, there is considerable bias against malleable implants on this platform, with people who have never had them claiming with authority that a malleable will never be truly comfortable or that the risk of constant pain and erosion with a semi-rigid devices are greater than with IPPs.

The rate of failure of IPPs is very real -there are multiple possible failure points- and with each successive surgery, the prospects of infection, scarring and reduced size all are worth considering when deciding which route to take.

On the other hand, if implanted correctly, a malleable implant may last for years -perhaps much longer than an IPP- and many men who have malleables claim that once they get used to their prosthesis, they stop becoming aware that they have one.

The rhetoric against malleable implants can at least partially be traced to the manufacturing companies pushing the more expensive devices and doctors doing the same (higher surgical fees), knowing that multiple surgeries potentially lie ahead.

At any rate, for those interested in malleable implants (or for those who have already been implanted with one), there is a whatapp group that one may join:

https://chat.whatsapp.com/FJYnpIGClI98xPWHAYxk3H

"ipp, the gold standard in malleable's" if they cost the same or less i still wouldn't' choose one . just looking at all that hardware that will go into your body and then fail later and have to be cut open again for a repeat performance is a hard pass for me .
meanwhile a malleable is always ready and nothing to malfunction .

What is the life expectancy of malleable implants? Lifetime??

anyone help me with the whatsapp? .. put it on an old iphone with no carrier service have it linked to the app on my computer but won't let me join the mallabble group? ... any ideas?

Pamen116 wrote:With the increase in IPP 3 piece failure- I believe people need to know their options when considering an implant.

I been on this forum for over 2 years now and I’ve seen little to no feedback/pictures on malleable.

For some of us young guys the smartest decision we can make is choosing an implant if we’ve exhausted ever other options in the market for ED, BUT as a young person it’s also difficult to imagine 3-4 revisions down the road when choosing to get implanted


Just some food for thought. Good day!

Perhaps I’m biased but I favor inflatable implants if I were to have the surgery done right now. I’m young and worry about the number of future revisions that would be required but I don’t like the idea of a constant hard-on. That being said, more discussion is always better, and it’s true that malleables aren’t discussed nearly as much as they should be. I would appreciate learning more about them.

I just created a dedicated malleable implant channel in the ED discord server I run. I would join Dapkin’s WhatsApp group but I don’t want to have my name and phone number publicly available. Discord lets you retain your privacy by just showing a chosen username like on FrankTalk while having the streamlined chat feature that makes the app valuable. It’s also accessible directly on PC, no need for a phone. Hopefully having another outlet for discussion can stimulate conversation. The server link is in my signature area if anyone is interested. Cheers

easymoney wrote:anyone help me with the whatsapp? .. put it on an old iphone with no carrier service have it linked to the app on my computer but won't let me join the mallabble group? ... any ideas?

When you say no carrier service I presume you mean that you do not have a cell phone number associated with that phone? Until you have a number provided by a cell phone company, you won't have a Whatsapp account (I believe Whatsapp is working on providing accounts even without a cell phone number, but that is still in the works).

If you do have a cell phone number, you can PM it to me and I will see if I could try to add you to the Whatsapp group.