Postby 1sfman » Thu Nov 12, 2026 8:39 am
Up4Real? wrote:ETGuy71 wrote:Having lived with a foreskin as an adult and then doing a circumcision, because I wanted it for several reasons, for me being circumcised is much better! That said, I do not understand why some on this site, mostly uncircumcised, are so against circumcision. If a guy wants to be circumcised it’s his choice, no one should question or ridicule.
ETGuy,
Thanks for your response.
My take on this is this is a site for learning about all such matters. There was no ridicule intended.
You are in a unique position as having experienced both aspects of the issue and could likely inform others of the benefits. Is that something you might do?
Thanks again.
Up4Real
The responses surrounding circumcision on FT are always interesting and sometimes very passionate. It's interesting considering that for each of us you are either circumcised or not and there's no way of knowing what the sensation/feeling is of being circumcised or not circumcised is unless you decide to get circumcised as an adult.
I was circumcised at birth, so I really have no way of knowing what having a full foreskin is like. I am lucky in that whoever performed the circumcision left the frenulum intact (whew!). I know some are not as lucky from research I've read and the frenulum was cut. Personally, I wish I had not been circumcised. Then, as others have done for a variety of reasons, I could have decided to have it done as an adult if I wanted to for whatever reason. But that decision was taken away 75 years ago without my consent.
My mother said she never asked that I be circumcised, but a nurse took me for a few minutes and when I was returned I had been circumcised. I did some research on that, and indeed in the 40's & 50's many U.S. hospitals performed routine newborn male circumcisions as an automatic default or standard hospital procedure rather than requiring explicit, individual informed consent as is standard today. I guess it's too late to sue them now

.
75 YO (1951). Happily married since 1972 (A couple since 1968). ED since age 60. Viagra, then Cialis, Trimix/Quadmix and VED. AMS 700 CX, 21cm + 1cm RTE left side, MS pump & 100cc reservoir. Implanted using Infrapubic procedure Jan 21, 2026.